Perfect Cacio e Pepe: The Original Roman Recipe

The Paradox of Simplicity

Cacio e Pepe is the most emblematic dish of Roman cuisine: only 3 ingredients, but considered one of the most difficult to execute perfectly. A dish that has made starred chefs cry and triumphed in the hands of Roman grandmothers.

Cacio e Pepe = Cheese (Pecorino) + Black Pepper + Cooking Water

No added fat, no eggs, no tricks. Only technique.

History of Cacio e Pepe

Cacio e Pepe

• Dry pasta (long preservation)
• Pecorino Romano (aged cheese)
• Black pepper (natural preservative)

pasta with little water, tossed with freshly grated Pecorino and pepper. A nutritious, caloric dish, simple to prepare with a campfire.

Today: International cult dish, served from Roman taverns to Michelin-starred restaurants.

Ingredients (4 people)

Only 3 Essential Ingredients

• ✅ Pasta: Tonnarelli 400g (traditional) or Spaghetti
• ✅ Pecorino Romano PDO: 150g freshly grated LAPA
• ✅ Black pepper: 8-10g whole peppercorns (grind immediately!)
• ✅ Water: For cooking pasta
• ✅ Salt: to taste (LITTLE! Pecorino is already salty)

Absolutely Forbidden

• ❌ Cream (sacrilege!)
• ❌ Butter, oil, other fats
• ❌ Parmigiano (instead of Pecorino)
• ❌ Eggs
• ❌ Garlic, onion, herbs
• ❌ Pre-grated Pecorino (doesn't melt!)

Black pepper:

Step-by-Step Recipe

1. Toast Black Pepper

Key ingredient: the pepper!

Procedure:

• Wide non-stick pan COLD
• Add 8-10g black peppercorns
• LOW heat
• Toast 2-3 minutes stirring
• Must release fragrance (NO smoke = burnt!)
• Turn off heat, cool 1 minute
• Grind COARSELY (mortar or coarse pepper mill)

Why toast?

• Releases essential oils
• Intensifies aroma
• Eliminates bitter notes
• Roman tradition

Procedure:

2. Grate Pecorino

FUNDAMENTAL: FRESH Pecorino!

Procedure:

• Pecorino Romano PDO aged 8-12 months
• Grate with FINE grater
• 150g for 4 people (generous!)
• Grate IMMEDIATELY (not before!)

Common mistake:

• Has anti-caking agents (doesn't melt!)
• Loses oils (doesn't mantecare!)
• Oxidized (rancid flavor)

FUNDAMENTAL: FRESH Pecorino!

3. Cook Pasta

Minimum water = easier mantecatura!

Traditional procedure:

• 4 liters water in pot
• Salt: 30g (7-8g/liter, LESS than usual!)
• Vigorous boil
• Tonnarelli: 8-9 min (2-3 min BEFORE al dente!)
• Spaghetti: 7-8 min

PROFESSIONAL TRICK (Minimum Water Method):

• Only 2 liters water (half of normal!)
• Salt: 20g
• Cooking with semi-open lid
• Stir often (otherwise sticks!)
• Advantage: More starchy water = perfect mantecatura!

PROFESSIONAL TRICK (Minimum Water Method):

4. Prepare Cream (Off Heat!)

CRITICAL MOMENT!

Method A: Pre-Mantecatura Cream (Recommended)

• Large bowl
• Grated Pecorino 150g
• Toasted ground pepper 8g (keep 2g for finish)
• HOT pasta water 100-150ml
• Mix VIGOROUSLY with whisk/fork
• Goal: Thick, smooth cream, NO lumps
• Consistency: Like thick Greek yogurt

CRITICAL MOMENT!

Method B: Direct Mantecatura (Traditional but difficult)

• Drain pasta (keep water!)
• Pan with pepper OFF HEAT
• Pasta + water 50ml
• Pecorino + water little at a time
• Mix frantically 2-3 minutes

Test:

5. Mantecatura (The Art!)

Pre-mantecatura cream procedure:

• Drain pasta al dente (2-3 min early!)
• Pan OFF HEAT with toasted pepper
• Add hot pasta
• Pour prepared Pecorino cream
• Mantecate VIGOROUSLY 1-2 minutes
• Movement: Up-down tossing the pan (chef move!)
• Add water if too thick (20-30ml at a time)
• Continue until creamy, velvety

Pan OFF HEAT

• Under 50°C = Pecorino doesn't melt (grainy)
• 55-60°C = PERFECT (creamy)
• Over 70°C = Pecorino clumps (stringy, rubbery)

Movement:

6. Plate

• Cacio e Pepe onto hot plate (heat plates!)
• Extra grated Pecorino on top (2-3 tablespoons)
• Freshly ground black pepper abundantly
• Serve IMMEDIATELY (cools in 60 seconds!)

Presentation:

• NO puddle of water on bottom (too liquid!)
• Creamy pasta, wrapped in white Pecorino veil
• Visible pepper, fragrant

The Science of Mantecatura

Why is Cacio e Pepe Difficult?

Pecorino Romano contains:

• 32% fats
• 26% proteins
• 36% water
• 6% minerals

When we heat Pecorino:

• 40-50°C: Fats melt
• 55-60°C: Perfect creamy emulsion (GOAL!)
• 65-70°C: Proteins coagulate = IT CLUMPS!
• 75°C+: Becomes stringy rubber = DISASTER

Solution:

• Al dente pasta (holds heat but not too much)
• Pan OFF HEAT (temperature control)
• Hot but not boiling water (dilutes gradually)
• Quick mantecatura (emulsion before cooling)

Role of Cooking Water

Pasta water contains:

• Starch (natural binder)
• Salt (emulsifier)
• Minerals (stabilizers)

Function:

• Dissolves Pecorino gradually
• Binds cheese fats with water (emulsion)
• Creates creamy consistency without cream
• Regulates final density

Water + Pecorino + Movement = Creamy emulsion

Common Mistakes (and Solutions)

❌ Mistake #1: Lumpy/Clumped Pecorino

Cause: Temperature too high, Pecorino added to boiling pasta

Solution:

• Pan OFF HEAT always!
• Pre-mantecatura cream (method A)
• If it clumps: add BOILING water and whisk fast

❌ Mistake #2: Liquid Cacio e Pepe

Cause:

Solution:

• Add water 20ml at a time
• Use 150g Pecorino for 400g pasta (generous!)
• Mantecate more (evaporates liquids)

❌ Mistake #3: Dry Pasta, Not Creamy

Cause:

Solution:

• Always keep 2 cups water aside
• Mantecate 2 full minutes
• Add water gradually until creamy

❌ Mistake #4: Flat Flavor

Cause:

Solution:

• Toast peppercorns and grind fresh!
• Use 8-10g pepper (generous!)
• Add extra pepper on top of dish

❌ Mistake #5: Too Salty

Cause:

Solution:

• Salt water LITTLE (7g/liter vs 10g normal)
• PDO Pecorino is already very savory!
• Taste before salting further

Variations and Reinterpretations

Cacio e Pepe with Guanciale = Gricia

Cause:

Creamy Cacio e Pepe (Starred Chef Method)

Aggiungere 20-30g burro durante mantecatura:

• Creamier
• Richer
• Less traditional but spectacular

Pasta alla Gricia

Crispy Cacio e Pepe

• Prepare normal Cacio e Pepe
• Pour into wide pan
• HIGH heat 2-3 minutes without stirring
• Form crispy crust on bottom
• Serve with crispy on top

NOTE:

Risotto-style Cacio e Pepe

• Toast pasta in pan (no separate cooking)
• Add boiling water little at a time
• Cook like risotto 12-15 minutes
• Mantecate with final Pecorino

Result:

Wine Pairings

Whites (Recommended)

• 🍷 Frascati Superiore DOCG - Classic Roman, savory, fresh
• 🍷 Verdicchio di Matelica Riserva - Structure, minerality
• 🍷 Pecorino (grape) Abruzzo - Appropriate name, fruity
• 🍷 Falanghina Campania - Fresh, floral
• 🍷 Greco di Tufo - Elegant, persistent

Light Reds

• 🍷 Cesanese del Piglio - Lazio DOC, spicy pepper (perfect pairing!)
• 🍷 Sangiovese di Romagna - Fresh, low tannin
• 🍷 Bardolino Chiaretto - Rosé, versatile

Falanghina Campania

FAQ Cacio e Pepe

Tonnarelli or Spaghetti?

Roman tradition: TONNARELLI (square-section spaghetti)

Why tonnarelli?

• Rough surface holds cream
• Square section (vs round spaghetti) = more surface
• Egg pasta (traditional Lazio)
• Perfect consistency

Acceptable alternatives:

• Spaghetti (more widespread, easier to find)
• Rigatoni (ridged surface, not traditional)
• Mezze maniche

AVOID:

• Smooth penne
• Short pasta (fusilli, farfalle)
• Soft fresh pasta (crumbles!)

Better Pecorino Romano or Parmigiano?

Acceptable alternatives:

Differences:

Caratteristica	Pecorino Romano	Parmigiano Reggiano
Milk	Sheep	Cow
Flavor	Savory, spicy	Sweet, delicate
Aging	5-12 months	12-36 months
Meltability	High (creamy!)	Medium (grainier)
Tradition	YES (original recipe)	NO (intrusion)

Compromise (if guests don't like Pecorino):

• 70% Pecorino + 30% Parmigiano
• Less savory, more delicate

Compromise (if guests don't like Pecorino):

Can I use Pecorino Sardo or Toscano?

Pecorino Romano PDO is the only correct one!

Pecorino differences:

Pecorino Romano PDO:

• Lazio/Sardinia/Grosseto
• Savory, spicy
• Aging 5-12 months
• Melts perfectly

Pecorino Sardo PDO:

• Sardinia
• Sweeter
• Less melting
• OK but not traditional

Pecorino Toscano PDO:

• Tuscany
• Very sweet, delicate
• Semi-aged soft
• NO for Cacio e Pepe (too sweet!)

Pecorino Sardo PDO:

How much Pecorino per person?

Generous formula: 35-40g/person

For 4 people (400g pasta):

• Mantecatura: 150g (37.5g/person)
• Final garnish: 20-30g extra
• Total: 170-180g

Adjustment:

• Light: 30g/person (120g total)
• Medium: 35g/person (140g total)
• Rich: 40g/person (160g total) ✅ RECOMMENDED
• Starred: 50g/person (200g total) 🌟

For 4 people (400g pasta):

How to store Pecorino Romano?

Optimal storage:

• Whole wheel: Waxed paper + fridge 2-6°C (lasts 6-12 months)
• Cut piece: Vacuum-sealed or food paper + fridge (3-4 months)
• Grated: Airtight container + fridge (MAX 3-4 days!)

DO NOT:

• Freeze (loses consistency)
• Direct plastic (sweats, molds)
• Room temperature (becomes rancid)

Whole wheel:

Can I prepare Cacio e Pepe in advance?

NO! Cacio e Pepe is a "moment" dish.

What can be prepared before:

• ✅ Toast pepper (max 2h before, store covered)
• ✅ Grate Pecorino (max 30 min before, cover!)
• ✅ Boil water
• ❌ Cooked pasta (becomes gluey)
• ❌ Mantecated cream (solidifies)

NO!

What can be prepared before:

• Add little milk (20-30ml)
• Heat non-stick pan
• Mantecate again
• Result: Decent but never like fresh!

LAPA Products for Perfect Cacio e Pepe

Pecorino Romano PDO LAPA

• ✅ PDO Certification Protection Consortium
• ✅ Aging 8-10 months (vs 5-8 standard)
• ✅ 100% sheep milk Lazio and Sardinia (traceability)
• ✅ Artisanal processing (selected small producers)
• ✅ Balanced flavor (savory but not excessive)
• ✅ Optimal meltability (guaranteed creaminess!)

Available formats:

• 250g freshly grated: €4.80 (convenient!)
• 500g piece: €9.50
• 1kg piece: €18
• 2kg wheel: €34

Why LAPA Pecorino?

• Extended aging = complex flavor
• Artisanal = superior quality
• Fresh = maximum creaminess
• PDO certified = origin guarantee

Available formats:

Tellicherry Black Pepper LAPA

• ✅ Origin India (Kerala, Tellicherry)
• ✅ Large peppercorns (4-5mm, best!)
• ✅ Hand-picked (quality selection)
• ✅ Intense aroma (essential oils 3-4%)
• ✅ Balanced spiciness (doesn't burn!)

Formats:

• 50g whole peppercorns: €3.20
• 100g peppercorns: €5.80
• 250g peppercorns: €13

Difference vs normal pepper:

• Larger peppercorns = more aromatic oils
• Elegant spiciness (not aggressive)
• Complex fragrance (floral, woody)
• Freshly ground enhances dish!

Balanced spiciness

Artisanal Tonnarelli LAPA

• ✅ Egg pasta (20% fresh eggs)
• ✅ Bronze die (rough surface!)
• ✅ Slow drying 24-36h (vs 3h industrial)
• ✅ 100% Italian durum wheat
• ✅ Artisanal production Lazio

Formats:

• 250g: €3.80
• 500g: €7

Egg pasta

Alternative: Bronze-drawn Gragnano IGP spaghetti (€4.50/500g)

Cacio e Pepe Kit LAPA

Complete Kit (4 people):

• Pecorino Romano PDO 200g freshly grated
• Tellicherry Black Pepper 25g peppercorns
• Artisanal Tonnarelli 500g
• Detailed recipe included

Why bronze die?

📧 [email protected] | 📞 +41 XX XXX XX XX | 🌐 www.lapa.ch/kit-cacio-pepe

Conclusion: Perfection in Simplicity

Perfect Cacio e Pepe is proof that Italian cuisine is art: 3 humble ingredients transformed into a sublime dish through technique, timing and passion.

The real difficulty? Not in the ingredients, but in the execution: perfect temperature, quick mantecatura, creamy emulsion. A dish that requires years to master.

3 final secrets:

• LAPA PDO Pecorino: Freshly grated, aged 8+ months (perfect meltability!)
• Toasted pepper: Tellicherry peppercorns toasted and ground immediately (explosive aroma!)
• Off-heat mantecatura: 55-60°C, continuous movement (creamy emulsion!)

you'll serve a Cacio e Pepe your customers will talk about for weeks.

Buona Cacio e Pepe!

---

Related Articles:

• Pecorino Romano DOP: La Guida Completa
• Gricia: La Madre della Cacio e Pepe
• Carbonara Perfetta: Ricetta Autentica
• Iconic Roman Sauce Tags: `cacio-e-pepe` `recipes`

Buona Cacio e Pepe!